Fight Fair: How to Disagree Without Destroying Your Marriage

In marriage, disagreements are inevitable, but how you handle them makes all the difference. On this episode of The Grace Marriage Podcast, hosts Brad and Marilyn Rhoads, alongside co-host Rick Dayton, discuss practical ways couples can engage in healthy disagreements without damaging their relationship. They explore “fighting fair” and offer biblical and practical wisdom for navigating these challenging moments.

---

Expect the Rapids: Why Planning Ahead Matters

Rick kicked off the conversation with a vivid analogy: rafting down a river filled with unpredictable white-water rapids. He emphasized the importance of having a plan before hitting rough waters in marriage. “We can’t wait until we’re in the thick of a disagreement to figure out how to stay in the boat.”

This truth applies to marriage, too. Establishing rules of engagement for conflict beforehand can keep you connected and reduce unnecessary damage when disagreements arise.

---

Healthy Guidelines for Disagreements

Brad and Marilyn shared practical strategies for navigating disagreements fairly and constructively:

1. Use “I” Statements Instead of “You” Accusations

Avoid pointing fingers. Instead of saying, “You never listen,” try “I feel unheard when I don’t get a chance to share my thoughts.” This approach reduces defensiveness and fosters understanding.

2. Avoid Absolutes Like “Always” and “Never”

Extreme language often triggers immediate defensiveness. Stick to specific observations rather than blanket statements.

3. Pause Before Speaking

“When you’re feeling hot and want to speak the most, that’s when you need to speak the least,” Brad advised. Slowing down allows emotions to cool and wisdom to prevail.

4. Seek Understanding First

Marilyn emphasized the importance of clarifying what your spouse actually said. “There are times he’s heard something completely different than what I thought came out of my mouth,” she shared. Try repeating back what you heard to confirm understanding.

5. Cover Every Step with Prayer

Both Brad and Marilyn recommend praying before approaching your spouse about a conflict. “It helps get your heart in the right place,” Marilyn explained. Whether together or individually, prayer invites God into the conversation and helps maintain a grace-filled perspective.

---

Don’t Panic: Keeping Perspective in Conflict

Brad highlighted the danger of blowing a single disagreement out of proportion. “Sometimes couples think they’re in crisis because they had one big fight, but in reality, their marriage is strong.” Keeping perspective helps couples avoid spiraling into negativity.

One key takeaway: conflict is normal. “You’re two different people with different backgrounds—you’re going to disagree,” Brad reminded listeners. The goal isn’t to eliminate disagreements but to learn how to navigate them well.

---

The Beauty of Growth Through Conflict

The episode wrapped up with an encouraging reminder: learning to disagree well takes time, but it leads to deeper intimacy and connection. “The way to get really bad at disagreeing is to never disagree,” Brad noted. Healthy conflict fosters growth and strengthens the bond between spouses.

---

Key Takeaway: Disagreements don’t have to be destructive. With intentionality, prayer, and grace, couples can learn to navigate conflict in a way that brings them closer together rather than driving them apart.

Want more practical insights? Listen to the full episode of The Grace Marriage Podcast and explore the show notes for helpful resources on building a healthy, grace-filled marriage.