On this episode of the Grace Marriage podcast, Brad sits down with longtime friend Brandon Swanner to revisit a disagreement over whether spouses respond well to constant correction. They discuss the “rebuke fast” Brad once challenged Brandon and his wife Tara to try, and how cutting back on correction and leaning into grace made their home noticeably more pleasant. The conversation covers why a spouse’s core personality rarely changes through correction, why kindness holds more influence than criticism, and practical tools like a 10-to-1 affirmation rule and a secure identity in Christ for extending grace more easily.
———-
Most of us enter marriage believing that pointing out our spouse’s flaws, gently, lovingly, and with the best of intentions, is part of the job. If you see something short of what you perceive the Bible’s standard to be, you say something. You remind them of the Bible. You remind them what you prefer. You correct, and you hope for the best.
It feels responsible. It may even feel spiritual. And it almost never works.
One couple learned this the hard way, early in their marriage. Their normal rhythm looked like this…one of them would mess up, the other would get frustrated, speak up, correct, and hope it landed. It rarely did. So they tried something different. They agreed to a rebuke fast: a month, maybe two, where they simply stopped correcting each other. Instead of pointing out what was wrong, they prayed about the significant issues and let the small ones go, the daily friction that comes from living with another human being who has their own preferences, their own patterns, their own way of doing things.
The results showed up almost immediately. Within two days, they realized just how often they’d been rebuking each other, because now it took real self-control to stop. The habit had been that automatic. By the end of the month, their home felt different. More pleasant. Lighter. Not because either of them had changed their behavior, but because they’d changed how much space they gave each other to simply be imperfect.
That doesn’t mean an offense never gets addressed. It means the couple got slower to bring it up. The flavor of a home shifts when grace becomes the default, when a spouse can offend you in small ways and know it’s safe, that you can absorb it without keeping score.
The Idiosyncrasies Aren’t Going Anywhere
Here’s the part that might sting a little: the things that annoy you about your spouse probably aren’t going to change. You married a human being with real patterns and a real personality, and years of gentle, or not so gentle, correction rarely rewires that.
Ask someone who’s been “coaching” their spouse for years to show you the progress, and usually there isn’t any. If a car hasn’t started after you’ve tried the same fix for six years straight, the fix isn’t working. It’s time to try something else.
What can change is you, specifically, your appreciation for how your spouse is made. Letting go of the demand that they be more like you, learning to appreciate them as they are, no longer needing to be upset every time something doesn’t go your way. There’s something almost countercultural about that kind of deference, laying down your preferences for someone else’s benefit. Some would call it Christlike. It doesn’t mean ignoring real sin or letting genuine problems fester. It means earning the right to speak by not spending your voice on every minor thing. This applies equally in both directions. Whichever spouse tends to speak up first and correct more often is the one this challenge is really for, and that role isn’t fixed. It shifts from couple to couple, and sometimes from season to season within the same marriage.
Whoever’s Kindest Has the Most Influence
Nobody enjoys being around someone who’s constantly correcting them. And in most marriages, if you ask each spouse who’s hardest on them, who seems most convinced they need to change, the answer is almost always: my spouse.
Compare that to the person who’s most impressed with you, most convinced you’re the best thing going. Ideally, that’s also your spouse. It’s a strange dynamic, and a beautiful one. Your spouse is the one human being on earth who knows every one of your faults, the outbursts, the things you shouldn’t have said, the failures nobody else saw, and still looks up to you, still respects you, still adores you.
That’s not a small thing. It’s the closest earthly picture we get of how God loves us: fully known, faults and all, and loved anyway, more than we can imagine.
The Plant in the Corner of the House
Picture a season where your spouse just isn’t thriving. They seem to be carrying a lot, and the connection between you has gone quiet. The easy reaction is frustration. Why aren’t they doing better?
A more useful picture is a plant left uncared for in the corner of a house, not watered, not given light, slowly wilting. It’s natural for something like that to struggle when it isn’t being tended to. Your spouse’s struggle might be less a flaw in them and more a reflection of the care and investment they’ve been receiving lately. Beautiful, thriving things thrive because they’ve received love, attention, and delight. When a spouse is struggling, that’s often the moment to pour in more, not to list the problems back to them. This isn’t a one-way responsibility that falls on one spouse alone. Both people in a marriage need tending, and both are capable of doing the tending.
Pull the Car Out of the Ditch
There’s an old picture worth borrowing here, close to the spirit of Ecclesiastes:. Pity the person who falls and has no one to help them up. Imagine driving past someone whose car is stuck in a ditch, wheels spinning, mud flying. Do you stand on the side of the road yelling at them to stop making ruts, stop throwing mud, stop getting you dirty? Or do you hook up a chain and pull them out?
That’s the choice in marriage, over and over. It’s easy to take offense at the mess, the mud, the spinning wheels, the visible symptoms of a spouse who’s struggling, instead of doing the harder, kinder thing: helping them out of the ditch. Love moves through pursuit, not through griping about how someone isn’t doing well. When a spouse needs you most, “would you please do better” has never once produced gratitude and a burst of motivation. It just doesn’t work that way.
The power’s in love. The power’s in pursuit.
Make Rebuke the Exception
A useful practical rule – ten pieces of affirmation for every piece of corrective input. Overlooking an offense promotes love. Rebuke becomes the rare exception, not the daily rhythm.
Think about the people in your own life you enjoy least, the ones where, if they call, you already know they’re upset about something. Every church, every workplace, has a short list of people like that. Nobody wants to be that person to their spouse.
But warning…you can’t fake this. Ten hollow compliments used as a runway to the real complaint don’t land the same way. People can tell. Genuine affirmation takes actual delight in the other person, which takes time, attention, prayer, and no small amount of self-control. Love is, in large part, self-control. It’s the ability to catch your initial reaction to whatever just happened, long enough to respond to the person in front of you instead of just reacting to them.
You Can’t Give What You Don’t Have
There’s a deeper thread running underneath all of this. How you see yourself determines how you see your spouse. People who feel like they’re constantly falling short, constantly striving to be enough, tend to be the most critical of others, because at least someone else is worse than they are. People who know they’re delighted in, who walk in the security of being fully known and fully loved, have far less difficulty extending that same delight outward.
For those who are Christians, this often comes back to identity. You’re not a burden God has to look away from. You’re fully known and still fully loved, secure rather than constantly striving. That kind of security is what makes real, non-performative affirmation possible. It’s hard to pour out grace you don’t believe you’ve received.
Even the way people talk about others gives them away. A few offhand comments about someone else in a person’s life often reveal more than an hour of them talking about themselves directly. If your words about your spouse, or your last church, or your last job, are laced with grace, that tells its own story. If they’re not, that’s worth examining too, since the pattern usually says more about the speaker than the subject.
The Takeaway
None of this means healthy criticism has no place in marriage. Real sin and real patterns of harm still need to be addressed, with wisdom, patience, and care. But for most couples, in most seasons, the daily friction isn’t sin. It’s just two different people living close together, bumping into each other’s preferences.
The instinct to fix, correct, and improve your spouse rarely produces the change you’re hoping for. What it produces is distance. The alternative, overlooking small offenses, assuming the best, pouring in delight and attention instead of critique, doesn’t just make your home more pleasant. It reflects, in a small and imperfect way, the way God loves us. He knows everything about us and choosing us anyway.
*This post is adapted from a conversation between Brad Rhoads and Brandon Swanner on the Grace Marriage Podcast. Learn more about building a stronger marriage and marriage ministry at gracemarriage.com.*
——-
What Most Churches Get Wrong About Marriage Ministry: Download
Discipling Marriage eBook: Download
——–
Like what you’re hearing??
✅ Subscribe & Share – Help us spread the message of grace-based marriage by subscribing to the Grace Marriage Podcast and sharing this episode with friends or family.
✅ Join Grace Marriage – Ready to invest in your marriage? Visit GraceMarriage.com to learn how proactive marriage care can transform your relationship and the marriages in your church.
✅ Leave a Review – Your feedback helps us reach more couples who need encouragement.
Follow Us:
📌 Facebook: facebook.com/gracemarriage
📌 Instagram: instagram.com/gracemarriage
📌 YouTube: youtube.com/@grace_marriage
AYVY5LSI8PC3CRN9
